One former student who testified Thursday was Yasmine Issa, a young divorced mother who sought a career as an ultrasound sonographer.
While he acknowledged that he has a financial stake � because he engages in short selling, or betting against companies or industries � he said, “It is my hope that there’s still time to do something, and that’s why I’m testifying here today.”
Hundreds of students have shared with Senator Harkin’s office their stories of being aggressively recruited and misled about the career and salary potential offered by for-profit schools.
Senators on the committee acknowledged the important role that the for-profit sector has played, particularly in meeting the needs of adult working students. But while some expressed outrage over what appear to them to be systemic problems, others urged caution against overregulating in response to what they see as a few bad apples.
Sen. Michael Enzi of Wyoming, the committee’s ranking Republican, urged using “a scalpel, not a machete.”
The fundamental problem, one witness said, is that the industry depends heavily on government loans, when the government bears all the risk if students default. The incentive is to enroll as many students as possible and charge high tuition to maximize the loans and grants that flow to the schools, said the witness, Steven Eisman.
“We don’t know what risk we are taking by investing an increasing share of our federal financial-aid dollars in this sector,” said Sen. Tom Harkin (D) of Iowa, who launched a series of hearings Thursday as chairman of the Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee. “We have a responsibility to ensure students are being well educated and that schools are using taxpayer dollars responsibly.”
Although nonprofit institutions still make up the majority of US colleges and universities, enrollment at for-profit colleges has grown by more than 200 percent in the past decade. Their flexible and convenient offerings, including online degrees,Miss Sixty, have been especially attractive to adult working students.
For-profit colleges have been motivated to grow as investors watch the value of the publicly traded schools. The resulting rapid growth spells trouble, Mr. Eisman said.
That’s one warning raised Thursday by a witness at a Senate hearing, as the schools come under government scrutiny for alleged practices driven more by profit margins than by educational goals.
Could for-profit colleges be the educational equivalent of the subprime-mortgage market?
Other practices that witnesses described include schools receiving loan or grant payments for students no longer enrolled, encouraging prospective students to buy illegitimate high school diplomas, and manipulating data to appear to be meeting federal requirements to qualify for student aid.
In the 1990s, a number of small for-profit schools were shut down for outright fraud. Today, the landscape is more complex.
“The for-profits now are regionally accredited colleges [and] big publicly traded corporations…. One can argue that they’re too expensive and criticize them for their default rates, but it’s not the same as saying they’re in a straight rip-off business,” says Kevin Carey, policy director of Education Sector in Washington, in a phone interview. “The bottom line is the reason this industry has grown is that they’re serving a market that the traditional colleges are either unwilling or unable to serve.”
Loopholes in current regulations have allowed troubling practices to continue � such as schools giving recruiters financial incentives for the number of students they enroll � according to witness Kathleen Tighe, the US Department of Education’s inspector general.
The Education Department recently released new proposed rules intended to close such loopholes and make information about for-profit colleges clearer to consumers.
Under one rule,Juicy Couture tracksuits, schools would have to provide prospective students with graduation and job-placement rates for various programs. A further development of a rule known as “gainful employment” is still in the works. It’s controversial because it could potentially hold for-profit schools accountable for whether their graduates earn average salaries high enough to enable them to pay off their debts.
Related:
When careers need reinvention
Rising college costs prompt student loan reform
Ms. Issa enrolled in a $32,000 program at the Sanford-Brown Institute in White Plains, N.Y., after officials there told her she’d be able to sit for a certification exam and get a job upon completion. When she went looking for ultrasound jobs, she was told the program was not accredited.
For-profit colleges currently enroll about 10 percent of all college students in the United States. But they receive about 23 percent of federal loans and grants, and their students default on loans at higher rates, according to a report released by the Senate committee that held the hearing.
A nearby community college offered an accredited program for half the cost, she found out later. She’s now saddled with $15,000 in federal student loans.
A defender of the sector expressed disappointment at a witness list made up primarily of critics. Harris Miller, president of the Career College Association, which lobbies on behalf of more than 1,800 for-profit schools, was not a witness but said in a written statement that in future hearings, he hopes “to work with [Harkin’s] committee to truly inform and educate on the value of private sector institutions and their role in achieving President Obama's goal of returning the US to number one in the world in higher education by 2020."
The portfolio manager for FrontPoint Financial Services Fund predicted the subprime-mortgage downfall. At the hearing, he drew a parallel to pushing through mortgages that people couldn’t afford.
PRODUCT DETAILS
Hot off the fall-winter collection is the show-stopping bootie, a sure hit with any style of mini dress or slim-fit pants. This leather option is highlighted by allover snakeskin print, pointed toe and concealed platform.
It’s been a long, cold fashion week in New York City, and I’m tired of wearing big,NBA, clunky boots. I started to fixate on the shoes in the front row of the Max Azria show yesterday — hot, high-heeled bootie pumps from Brian Atwood and YSL!
The designer pumps that the ladies on the runway were wearing average at about $775. I decided after the show that I was going to play a little hooky from work and go buy an affordable pair.
I came across these Desano heeled booties at Aldo, and they’re on sale for only $80! The height and the heel — that is actually quite slimming — really work here.
- Material: Leather
- Sole: Synthetic
- 2.5-inch heel
Get more Us! Follow us on Twitter, Friend us on Facebook, Subscribe to Us Weekly
By Sasha Charnin Morrison for UsMagazine.com. To read more of the Recessionista blog,Victorias Secret, click here.
I can see these going with everything. You can pair with florals, racy grey denim, pencil skirts, whatever. Now, here’s hoping they can lead me to a better mood when i look down at my feet the rest of winter!
Buy it here.
Smet is what happens when icons collaborate. It is a line of rock and roll threads showcasing the design talent of Christian Audigier and his rock and roll hero Johny Hallyday.
Audigier has been cementing his place as a denim king since the age of 19 with jobs at Levi抯, Fierucci, Diesel, Bsiou Bsiou, American Eagle Outfitters and Von Dutch. In 2004 he announced he would be leaving Von Dutch to debut his own line of clothing and accessories inspired by American culture, motorcycle culture and the art of tattoos. Influenced greatly by the Godfather of tattoo抯 Audigier named his line Ed Hardy. Using his creative genius and Hardy抯 tattoo legendry the label flourished spawning energy drinks, motorcycles and a pending house ware抯 line. Audigier then set his sights on achieving a dream: to collaborate with his idol Johny Hallyday.
Smet is a line of tees, tanks, denim, polos, caps and accessories designed to chronicle the career and vivacious personality of Hallyday. The graphic tees include spades, crests, animals, and all things rock and roll. The line is worn by Chris Brown, Tyrese, Nas, Shakira, Marilyn Manson, Madonna and America抯 Next Top Model Caridee English.
